What Is Buckling in Steel? — Types, Causes and Effective Length

🤔 Why Does Buckling Matter?

In steel design, a member can fail in two different ways: strength failure or stability failure.

A strength failure occurs when the steel reaches its strength limit. But a slender steel member can become unstable and buckle before the steel itself reaches its yield strength.

This is particularly important for columns, struts, braces, and slender beams subjected to compression or bending. Therefore, checking stability is an essential part of steel design.

A real-world example - buckling failure:

The importance of buckling can be seen in the Quebec Bridge collapse of 1907, where the failure of compression members contributed to the progressive collapse of the bridge.

The key lesson is: a steel member does not always need to reach its material strength to fail. It can fail because it becomes unstable.

❓ What is buckling in steel?

Buckling is the sudden sideways deflection of a slender member under compression caused by instability rather than by the material running out of strength.

Think of pressing down on a plastic ruler. At first, the ruler stays straight as you increase the load. But after reaching a certain load, it suddenly bends sideways.The ruler has not necessarily broken because its material has reached its strength. Instead, it has lost stability.

A slender steel member can behave in a similar way.

Strength failure vs. buckling

There are two different failure mechanisms to understand:

• Strength failure (crushing): the stress in the steel reaches its resistance. This is more likely to govern for short, stocky members.
• Stability failure (buckling): the member becomes unstable and deflects sideways before the steel reaches its yield strength. This is more likely to govern for long, slender members.

To determine whether a compression member will fail by buckling or by material strength, an important variable — the critical load — was introduced in the 18th century.

🔑 Key Concept: Euler's Critical load

In the 18th century, Leonhard Euler worked out the load at which an ideal, perfectly straight column becomes unstable:

🏗️ The five types of buckling in steel members

Buckling is not just one phenomenon. Depending on the shape of the member and how it is loaded, a steel member can lose stability in five common ways.

1. Flexural buckling

The column bends sideways about its weak axis, which is the direction in which the section is least stiff. This is the classic column buckling case and the one Euler's formula describes. It is the most common mode in columns, struts and braces.

2. Torsional buckling

The column twists about its length without bending sideway. It is mainly a concern for open sections with low torsional stiffness, such as cruciform (cross-shaped) sections.

3. Flexural-torsional buckling

Above buckling mode (bending and twisting) happen at the same time. This is typical for singly symmetric or asymmetric open sections such as angles, tees and channels, where the shear center and the centroid do not coincide.

4. Lateral-torsional buckling

In a beam, the top flange is in compression and behaves like a long, thin column. If the beam is not restrained sideways, the compression flange moves out and the section twists. Deep, narrow, unrestrained I-beams are the most at risk.

5. Local buckling

Individual plate elements — a thin flange or web — can buckle before the member as a whole does. Whether this happens is governed by the width-to-thickness ratio of each element, which is exactly what section classification checks: a Class 4 section must be reduced to its effective area.

Summary of the types of buckling

🧩 What is the factors affecting the buckling?

The more slender a member is, the more sensitive it becomes to stability. Its behaviour depends not only on the strength of the steel, but also on factors such as:

• ⬆️ member length or slenderness → ⬆️ Buckling risk
• ⬆️ Cross-section stiffness → ⬇️ Buckling risk
• ⬆️ End restraint → ⬇️ Effective length → ⬇️ Buckling risk
• ⬆️ Lateral restraint → ⬇️ Effective length → ⬇️ Buckling risk
• ⬆️ Initial imperfections or residual stresses → ⬆️ Buckling risk

📏 Key Concept: Effective length

The effective length L_cr is the length of an equivalent pinned-pinned column that would buckle at the same load as the real member.

Two columns can have the same section and the same actual length yet very different buckling loads. What changes is how their ends are held:

Effective length factors for common end conditions

Braced and sway frames

• Braced (non-sway) frames: bracing or shear walls stop sideways movement, so columns usually get K of 1.0 or less.
• Unbraced (sway) frames: the frame relies on its own stiffness and can sway, so K is usually greater than 1.0 — these columns are much more vulnerable to buckling.

Worked example — the same 4 m column, different ends

Take a steel column with L = 4 m and compare two end conditions:

🛡️ How to reduce buckling risk

Therefore, to reduce the buckling effect to a steel structural, below :

• Brace to shorten the unbraced length. Bracing a column at mid-height halves L_cr — which multiplies the buckling load by four.
• Restrain the weak axis. Flexural buckling usually happens about the weak axis, so brace the direction in which the section is least stiff.
• Choose sections with a large radius of gyration — hollow sections and well-balanced shapes put more area away from the centroid.
• Don't assume perfect fixity. Real connections are rarely fully rigid, so use conservative K values.
• Restrain the compression flange of beams to control lateral-torsional buckling.

🙋 Frequently asked questions

📋 Key takeaways

1. Buckling is a stability failure, not a strength failure.
2. There are 5 modes of buckling, which are flexural buckling, torsional buckling, flexural-torsional buckling, lateral-torsional buckling and local buckling.
3. Euler's Critical load N_cr = (π²EI)/(L_cr)² defines elastic critical load at which buckling occurs.
4. The effective length is determined based on the member length and its restraint conditions. It is an important factor in calculating the elastic critical load.
5. To reduce the risk of buckling, bracing can be added, sections with a larger radius of gyration can be selected, and the restraint conditions can be modified.

📄 Need a steel section check in your design report?

Buckling decides which part of your section you are allowed to use. If you want a ready-to-submit design report that runs the classification and the full cross-section check with your own I-section, CHS or RHS in eurocode 3, feel free to try our application — what you need is just the design data values, and a ready-to-submit PDF report will be generated in a minute.